https://unicorn.bogomips.org accepts client certificate?

https://unicorn.bogomips.org accepts client certificate?

[Shota Fukumori (sora_h)]

Hi,

I found that https://unicorn.bogomips.org/ accepts client certificate.
My browser prompts what certificate to use for a connection, even
https://unicorn.bogomips.org/ doesn't require a client certificate.

I and my colleagues are surprised about browser asking it. I guess
this is unexpected behavior, is it expected?

Re: https://unicorn.bogomips.org accepts client certificate?

[Eric Wong]

"Shota Fukumori (sora_h)" <her@sorah.jp> wrote:
> Hi,
> 
> I found that https://unicorn.bogomips.org/ accepts client certificate.
> My browser prompts what certificate to use for a connection, even
> https://unicorn.bogomips.org/ doesn't require a client certificate.

+Cc yahns-public@yhbt.net

Likely a bug in yahns or the OpenSSL configuration of it.

I have also been running some experimental ruby-trunk or
yahns patches related to https://bugs.ruby-lang.org/issues/12126
so maybe I left something out in a deployment[1]...

Which client(s) are you using?

curl, w3m, lynx on both Debian jessie and wheezy all seem fine.

  openssl s_client -connect unicorn.bogomips.org:443 -CApath /etc/ssl/

Also seems fine.  As does the following Ruby snippet:

  require 'uri'
  require 'net/https'
  uri = URI('https://unicorn.bogomips.org/')
  req = Net::HTTP::Get.new(uri)
  res = Net::HTTP.start(uri.hostname, uri.port, use_ssl: true) do |http|
    p http.request(req)
  end

I suppose there will be problems with old clients that can't
handle SNI or newer/stronger encryption.

> I and my colleagues are surprised about browser asking it. I guess
> this is unexpected behavior, is it expected?

I've not advertised the https site for unicorn yet;
it's just an experiment at this point[2]

Given the flurry of 1.12.x releases regarding TLS issues in
yahns, it's safe to say there are likely bugs how yahns does
TLS:

  http://yhbt.net/yahns-public/20160229-yahns-1.12.2-unle@shed/t/

Fwiw, here's the OpenSSL SSLContext config I use with yahns 1.12.2

  require 'openssl'
  ctx = OpenSSL::SSL::SSLContext.new
  ctx.cert = OpenSSL::X509::Certificate.new(IO.read(
    '/etc/ssl/certs/dcvr.yhbt.net.crt'))
  ctx.extra_chain_cert = [ OpenSSL::X509::Certificate.new(IO.read(
    '/etc/ssl/certs/dcvr.yhbt.net.chain.crt')) ]
  ctx.key = OpenSSL::PKey::RSA.new(IO.read(
    '/etc/ssl/private/dcvr.yhbt.net.key'))
  ctx.set_params

I'm really not that knowledgeable when it comes to OpenSSL[3].

Is there a WEBrick or similar pure Ruby config you can mimic
the problem with?



[1] Anyways I'm on yahns 1.12.2, now, my curl check runs
    periodically and never reported any TLS-related error
    in weeks.

[2] And will remain experimental indefinitely given my
    lack-of-trust in both the CA system and the quality
    of OpenSSL itself.

[3] I'm afraid my attempt to use/read the openssl C library
    code back in the the 2000s traumatized me for good :x

Re: https://unicorn.bogomips.org accepts client certificate?

[Shota Fukumori (sora_h)]

Confirmed at least Chrome, Safari, Firefox on OS X El Capitan, and
Microsoft Edge on Windows 10.

> I've not advertised the https site for unicorn yet;

I thought so too, but at least google is using https url for their
search result.


--
Shota Fukumori a.k.a. @sora_h http://sorah.jp/

Re: https://unicorn.bogomips.org accepts client certificate?

[russm]

On Tue, Mar 15, 2016 at 06:21:01PM +0900, Shota Fukumori (sora_h) wrote:
> Confirmed at least Chrome, Safari, Firefox on OS X El Capitan, and
> Microsoft Edge on Windows 10.

FWIW, I see this with Chrome 49 on OSX 10.11, but *not* Chrome 49 on
Debian 8.

Re: https://unicorn.bogomips.org accepts client certificate?

[Shota Fukumori (sora_h)]

To be clear, you have to have a client certificate on your certificate
manager to be prompted.
Server doesn't specify acceptable client certificate CA names, so any
client certificate is ok.

On Tue, Mar 15, 2016 at 6:43 PM, russm <russm-rubyforge@slofith.org> wrote:
> On Tue, Mar 15, 2016 at 06:21:01PM +0900, Shota Fukumori (sora_h) wrote:
>> Confirmed at least Chrome, Safari, Firefox on OS X El Capitan, and
>> Microsoft Edge on Windows 10.
>
> FWIW, I see this with Chrome 49 on OSX 10.11, but *not* Chrome 49 on
> Debian 8.



-- 
Shota Fukumori a.k.a. @sora_h http://sorah.jp/

Re: https://unicorn.bogomips.org accepts client certificate?

[Eric Wong]

"Shota Fukumori (sora_h)" <her@sorah.jp> wrote:
> To be clear, you have to have a client certificate on your certificate
> manager to be prompted.
> Server doesn't specify acceptable client certificate CA names, so any
> client certificate is ok.

Thanks for the report, I think I just fixed the problem:

  ctx.set_params # reasonable defaults for clients, apparently

However, webrick and drb both set VERIFY_NONE for servers:

  ctx.set_params(verify_mode: OpenSSL::SSL::VERIFY_NONE)

I've updated https://unicorn.bogomips.org/ with the above change,
can you confirm it works for you?  If so, I'll update the yahns
documentation.

Re: https://unicorn.bogomips.org accepts client certificate?

[Shota Fukumori (sora_h)]

On Wed, Mar 16, 2016 at 8:30 AM, Eric Wong <e@80x24.org> wrote:
> I've updated https://unicorn.bogomips.org/ with the above change,
> can you confirm it works for you?  If so, I'll update the yahns
> documentation.

It worked -- my browser now doesn't prompt about a certificate :)

-- 
Shota Fukumori a.k.a. @sora_h http://sorah.jp/